TM

THE ART AND SCIENCE OF

BREWING

© 2024 Jeffrey W. Bulger

Traditional Techniques

Modern Innovations

and Future Trends 

Select header or footer for
Table of Contents

Chapter 2: Malt, Adjuncts, and Sugars

Abstract: Malt, adjuncts, and sugars are the fundamental ingredients in brewing, each playing a crucial role in determining the flavor, aroma, color, and overall quality of beer. Malt, primarily derived from barley, undergoes processes like germination and kilning to develop the enzymes essential for brewing. Adjuncts, such as corn, rice, wheat, and oats, supplement malted barley to lighten body, add flavor, or reduce costs. Various sugars, including corn sugar and cane sugar, are used to increase fermentable extract and adjust the flavor profile. This chapter delves into the historical context, biochemical properties, and practical applications of these ingredients. By exploring the evolution of malting techniques from ancient civilizations to modern scientific advancements, brewers gain insight into optimizing ingredient selection. The chapter also emphasizes the importance of rationalism, empiricism, and the scientific method in refining brewing practices, ensuring consistent quality and enabling the creation of innovative beer styles.

**

From grain to glass, the harmony of malt, adjuncts, and sugars composes a symphony of flavors.

Imagine walking into a bustling brewery, the air filled with the rich aroma of grains and the subtle sweetness of fermenting sugars. This sensory experience starts with the fundamental ingredients of brewing: malt, adjuncts, and sugars. Picture malted barley being transformed through processes of germination and kilning, and adjuncts like corn and rice adding unique flavors and textures. Understanding their roles and transformations is crucial for any brewer, from the novice homebrewer to the seasoned professional. In brewing, the selection of malt, adjuncts, and sugars plays a critical role in determining the flavor, aroma, color, and overall quality of the beer. Each ingredient brings unique properties that influence the brewing process and the final product. Understanding these components allows brewers to craft beers with precise characteristics and consistent quality. This chapter delves into the intricacies of malt, adjuncts, and sugars, exploring their historical context, chemical properties, and practical applications in brewing.

Malt, primarily derived from barley, is the cornerstone of beer production. Barley undergoes germination and kilning to become malt, a process that modifies the grain’s endosperm and activates enzymes essential for brewing. The modification of the endosperm correlates with the growth of the acrospire, which determines the grain’s crushability and the starch’s convertibility into sugars by enzymes formed during germination. The process of malting begins with steeping, where barley is soaked in water to trigger germination. After steeping, the grain is allowed to germinate, during which enzymes like amylases develop, breaking down the starches into simpler sugars. Once the acrospire grows to a desired length, the germination process is halted by drying the grain in a kiln. The kilning process not only dries the malt but also develops its flavor and color characteristics. Higher kilning temperatures produce darker malts with more complex flavors, while lower temperatures yield lighter malts with higher enzymatic activity.

Diastatic power is a measurement of the malt’s enzyme content, indicating the malt’s ability to convert starches into fermentable sugars. High diastatic power is essential for efficient starch conversion, especially when using adjuncts like rice or corn, which lack their own enzymes. Malts with high diastatic power can convert not only their own starches but also those of adjuncts, making them versatile in various brewing applications. The protein content of malt influences the beer’s clarity and stability. Higher protein levels can lead to haze, while well-modified malts with a high percentage of soluble nitrogen result in less haze and better foam stability. The balance of proteins and nitrogen also affects the mouthfeel and head retention of the beer. Malts with low protein content are preferred for producing clear beers, while those with higher protein levels may be used to enhance body and foam.

The degree of kilning affects the malt’s color, measured in degrees Lovibond or European Brewing Convention (EBC) units. Kilning at higher temperatures produces darker malts with more complex flavors but reduces enzymatic activity. The color of the malt influences the final hue of the beer, ranging from pale gold to deep brown. Brewers carefully select malts based on the desired color and flavor profile of their beer. Six-row barley has higher enzyme and protein content compared to two-row barley, making it suitable for adjunct-heavy brews. Its thick husk contributes to higher tannin levels, which can cause haze and astringency if not managed properly. Six-row malt is often used in American lagers, where adjuncts like corn and rice are added to lighten the body and flavor. The high diastatic power of six-row malt ensures the complete conversion of starches from both the malt and adjuncts.

Two-row barley is preferred for its lower protein and tannin content, resulting in clearer, less astringent beers. It has a thinner husk and provides a cleaner malt profile, making it ideal for various beer styles. Two-row malt is the standard choice for many craft brewers due to its balance of flavor, enzymatic activity, and clarity. It forms the backbone of a wide range of beer styles, from pale ales to stouts. The standard British malt, pale ale malt, undergoes a long kilning process, resulting in rich, biscuity flavors. Its lower enzymatic activity necessitates careful mashing but contributes to the malt-forward character of traditional British ales. Pale ale malt is known for its ability to produce complex, flavorful beers with a distinctive malt character. It is often used in English-style ales, where malt flavor is a dominant feature.

Adjuncts are unmalted grains or other fermentable materials added to the mash to supplement malted barley. They can lighten the body, add flavor, or reduce costs. Common adjuncts include corn, rice, barley, wheat, oats, and rye. They must be cooked to gelatinize their starches before mashing. Corn is a popular adjunct in American brewing, adding sweetness and smoothness to beer. It lowers the protein and tannin content, reducing haze and lightening the body. Corn is often used in lagers to produce a clean, crisp profile. The sweetness of corn complements the hop bitterness in many light lagers, making them more palatable. Used similarly to corn, rice imparts a light, clean flavor. It is a key ingredient in many mass-produced lagers, contributing to their mild taste and clarity. Rice reduces the protein and tannin content, lightening the body without adding significant flavor. This makes rice an excellent adjunct for creating beers with a smooth, clean finish.

Other adjuncts like barley, wheat, oats, and rye add body, flavor, and complexity to beer. Barley enhances malt character, wheat improves head retention and mouthfeel, oats contribute creaminess, and rye adds a spicy note. These adjuncts are commonly used in specialty and craft beers to create unique profiles. For example, wheat is a key ingredient in wheat beers and Belgian-style witbiers, while oats are often used in stouts to add a rich, creamy texture. Sugars are used in brewing to increase fermentable extract and adjust the flavor profile of the beer. While they are not typically used in lagers, they can enhance the complexity of ales. Different sugars contribute varying degrees of fermentability and flavor.

Corn sugar, or dextrose, is 100% fermentable and often used for priming because it ferments quickly and completely, adding alcoholic strength without leaving residual sweetness. However, excessive use can lead to a thin body and a cidery off-flavor. Corn sugar is popular among homebrewers for its ease of use and predictability in fermentation. Cane sugar, or sucrose, when used in brewing, can impart a cidery taste. However, partially refined forms like light and dark brown sugar contribute a rum-like flavor that can be desirable in certain ale styles. The caramel and molasses notes from brown sugar add depth and complexity to darker ales. Grain sugars, derived from unmalted grains, are produced using acid or enzymatic conversion. Grain syrups and extracts provide fermentable sugars while imparting the grain’s characteristic flavors. They are often used in commercial brewing to increase fermentable extract without altering the beer’s flavor profile significantly.

The use of malt, adjuncts, and sugars in brewing dates back to ancient civilizations. The Sumerians and Egyptians utilized primitive malting techniques and local grains to produce fermented beverages. These early brewers relied on empirical observations, noting which methods produced desirable flavors and effects. The discovery of fermentation likely occurred by accident when wild yeasts fermented grain mixtures left out in the open. These ancient brewers observed the results and refined their techniques over time, creating the first rudimentary beers. During the medieval period, monastic breweries in Europe refined brewing techniques. Monks meticulously recorded their processes, leading to improved consistency and quality. The use of different malts and adjuncts became more sophisticated, with brewers experimenting to achieve specific characteristics in their beers. The development of brewing logs and the exchange of knowledge among monasteries contributed to the standardization of brewing practices. Monks also began to understand the importance of sanitation and temperature control, further enhancing the quality of their brews.

The 19th century brought scientific advancements that transformed brewing. The discovery of yeast’s role in fermentation and the development of malting technology allowed for greater control over the brewing process. Modern brewers now have access to a wide variety of malts, adjuncts, and sugars, each with specific properties that can be manipulated to achieve desired outcomes. The industrialization of brewing introduced precision and consistency, enabling large-scale production of high-quality beer. Advances in microbiology and chemistry have provided brewers with tools to analyze and optimize every aspect of the brewing process.

Rationalism plays a crucial role in understanding the biochemical principles behind malt, adjuncts, and sugars. By applying deductive reasoning, brewers can predict how different ingredients will affect the brewing process and the final product. Understanding how enzymes like amylases break down starches into fermentable sugars allows brewers to optimize mashing conditions. For example, knowing that higher kilning temperatures reduce enzymatic activity can guide the selection of malts for specific beer styles. This knowledge helps brewers achieve consistent starch conversion and control the fermentability of the wort. The relationship between protein content and beer clarity informs decisions about malt selection and adjunct use. Low-protein malts and adjuncts can reduce haze, while well-modified malts provide the necessary nitrogen for yeast health without excessive protein. Managing nitrogen levels is crucial for preventing off-flavors and ensuring a stable, clear beer.

The degree of kilning affects the color and flavor of the malt, influencing the beer’s final appearance and taste. Understanding the chemical changes that occur during kilning allows brewers to select malts that contribute the desired characteristics to their beer. This rational approach helps brewers create beers with precise color and flavor profiles. Empiricism involves gathering data through observation and experimentation. Brewers use inductive reasoning to identify patterns and optimize brewing practices based on empirical evidence. Observing the effects of different malting techniques on enzyme activity and protein levels helps brewers select the best malts for their recipes. Empirical data on how various malts perform under different conditions informs decisions about malt blends and mashing techniques. Continuous experimentation with malting processes leads to improvements in malt quality and performance.

Experimenting with different adjuncts allows brewers to understand their impact on flavor, body, and clarity. Empirical observations guide the use of adjuncts to achieve specific beer characteristics. For example, trials with rice and corn can reveal their effects on lightness and smoothness, while experiments with oats and rye can enhance body and flavor. Testing different types and amounts of sugars helps brewers determine their effects on fermentation and flavor. Empirical data on sugar fermentability and impact on taste inform decisions about sugar additions. Controlled experiments with various sugars enable brewers to create balanced and complex ales without undesirable off-flavors.

The scientific method provides a structured approach to advancing brewing techniques. By applying observation, hypothesis formation, experimentation, data analysis, replicability, and peer review, brewers can make significant strides in understanding and optimizing the use of malt, adjuncts, and sugars. A brewery set out to improve the consistency of its pale ales by optimizing malt modification. They hypothesized that adjusting the germination time and kilning temperature could enhance the malt’s enzymatic activity and flavor profile. By conducting controlled experiments with different germination periods and kilning temperatures, they collected data on enzyme levels, nitrogen content, and sensory characteristics. The results indicated that a slightly extended germination period, combined with moderate kilning, produced malt with high diastatic power and desirable flavor attributes. Peer-reviewed studies validated these findings, leading to a new standard for malt modification that improved the consistency and quality of the brewery’s pale ales.

A craft brewery aimed to create a smooth, creamy stout by incorporating oats into the mash. They hypothesized that using oats would enhance the beer’s mouthfeel and body. The brewery conducted experiments with varying proportions of oats, monitoring the impact on viscosity, head retention, and flavor. Empirical data showed that a 10% addition of oats provided the desired creamy texture without overwhelming the malt profile. After being verified by replication and peer review, the findings were shared with the brewing community, leading to widespread adoption of oats in stout recipes and inspiring further experimentation with other adjuncts. A brewery specializing in Belgian-style ales sought to refine its sugar addition practices to achieve a balanced flavor profile. They hypothesized that using different types of cane sugar would affect the beer’s fermentation dynamics and taste. The brewery conducted trials with various forms of cane sugar, including light and dark brown sugar, monitoring the impact on fermentation rate, alcohol content, and sensory attributes. Data analysis revealed that light brown sugar contributed subtle caramel notes, while dark brown sugar added more pronounced molasses flavors. By adjusting the sugar additions based on these findings, the brewery achieved a well-balanced Belgian ale with complex flavors and smooth fermentation.

Brewers have faced numerous challenges throughout history, from maintaining consistency to preventing spoilage. Evidence-based solutions and troubleshooting tips have been developed to address these challenges. Ongoing research and potential future directions continue to explore ways to improve brewing practices. Common problems, such as haze formation, high protein and tannin levels can cause haze in beer. Using low-protein malts and adjuncts, along with proper mashing techniques, can mitigate this issue. Employing fining agents and cold conditioning can also improve clarity. Incorrect malt or adjunct selection can lead to undesirable flavors. Understanding the properties of each ingredient and how they interact is key to achieving balanced recipes. Adjusting malt blends and adjunct proportions based on empirical data helps create harmonious flavor profiles.

Using well-modified malts with high diastatic power and low protein content can improve clarity and fermentation efficiency. Selecting malts based on their modification levels ensures consistent enzyme activity and reduces haze potential. Techniques like step mashing can enhance enzyme activity and improve the conversion of starches to fermentable sugars. Understanding the biochemical principles behind mashing allows brewers to select the best method for their recipes. Experimentation with different adjuncts can reveal their impact on flavor, body, and clarity, allowing brewers to fine-tune their recipes. Empirical observations from test batches help identify the optimal use of adjuncts to achieve specific beer characteristics.

Malt, adjuncts, and sugars are fundamental components of brewing, each contributing unique properties that influence the final product. By understanding the historical context, biochemical principles, and practical applications of these ingredients, brewers can create beers with precise characteristics and consistent quality. The interplay between rationalism, empiricism, and the scientific method is crucial for advancing brewing practices and achieving optimal results. The history of brewing is a rich tapestry that weaves together ancient traditions, medieval innovations, industrial advancements, and modern technological breakthroughs. From the earliest brews of Mesopotamia and Egypt to the refined techniques of medieval monks, and from the industrial-scale production of the 19th century to the craft beer revolution of today, the evolution of brewing reflects humanity’s enduring passion for this remarkable beverage. The continuous interplay of rationalism, empiricism, and the scientific method has driven the development of brewing practices, ensuring that beer remains a dynamic and exciting field. As we look to the future, the integration of tradition and innovation promises to keep the world of beer vibrant and evolving.

**

Review Questions

True/False Questions

1. True or False: The heart of brewing lies in the fundamental ingredients of malt, adjuncts, and sugars, which are the building blocks of beer.

2. True or False: Malt is primarily derived from wheat and undergoes germination and kilning to become malt.

3. True or False: Diastatic power is a measurement of the malt’s enzyme content and is crucial for efficient starch conversion.

4. True or False: Adjuncts are unmalted grains or other fermentable materials added to the mash to supplement malted barley.

5. True or False: Corn sugar is often used for priming because it ferments quickly and completely, adding alcoholic strength without leaving residual sweetness.

Multiple Choice Questions

6. Which process in malt production involves soaking barley in water to trigger germination?
A) Kilning
B) Mashing
C) Steeping
D) Boiling

7. Which of the following is a common adjunct used in American brewing to add sweetness and smoothness to beer?
A) Rye
B) Wheat
C) Corn
D) Oats

Brewer Vignettes

8. Brewer Vignette 1: You are a brewer in a modern brewery looking to optimize your pale ale production. You hypothesize that adjusting the germination time and kilning temperature could enhance the malt’s enzymatic activity and flavor profile. Describe the process you would follow and the potential results.
A) Ignore germination time and focus only on kilning temperature.
B) Conduct controlled experiments with different germination periods and kilning temperatures, then analyze enzyme levels, nitrogen content, and sensory characteristics.
C) Use the same germination time and kilning temperature for all batches.
D) Only vary the germination time without changing the kilning temperature.

9. Brewer Vignette 2: As a craft brewer, you want to create a smooth, creamy stout by incorporating oats into the mash. Explain how you would experiment with varying proportions of oats and what characteristics you would monitor.
A) Only use oats without considering proportions.
B) Experiment with varying proportions of oats, monitoring viscosity, head retention, and flavor.
C) Use oats at a fixed proportion in all batches.
D) Focus on other ingredients and ignore oats.

10. Brewer Vignette 3: You aim to refine your sugar addition practices to achieve a balanced flavor profile in your Belgian-style ale. Describe how you would test different types and amounts of sugars and what you would look for in the results.
A) Use only one type of sugar in all batches.
B) Conduct trials with various forms of cane sugar, monitoring fermentation rate, alcohol content, and sensory attributes.
C) Avoid using sugars in the brewing process.
D) Use random amounts of sugar without testing.

**

Correct Answers
True/False Questions

1. True

2. False (Malt is primarily derived from barley.)

3. True

4. True

5. True

Multiple Choice Questions

6. C) Steeping
7. C) Corn

Brewer Vignettes

8. B) Conduct controlled experiments with different germination periods and kilning temperatures, then analyze enzyme levels, nitrogen content, and sensory characteristics.
9. B) Experiment with varying proportions of oats, monitoring viscosity, head retention, and flavor.
10. B) Conduct trials with various forms of cane sugar, monitoring fermentation rate, alcohol content, and sensory attributes.

**

Beyond The Chapter

  • Bamforth, Charles W. “Beer: Tap into the Art and Science of Brewing.” Oxford University Press, 2009.
  • Fix, George. “Principles of Brewing Science: A Study of Serious Brewing Issues.” Brewers Publications, 1999.
  • Palmer, John J. “How to Brew: Everything You Need to Know to Brew Great Beer Every Time.” Brewers Publications, 2017.
  • White, Chris, and Jamil Zainasheff. “Yeast: The Practical Guide to Beer Fermentation.” Brewers Publications, 2010.
  • Brewers Association and American Homebrewers Association websites for articles, forums, and educational resources.

Weblinks

These references offer comprehensive insights into Malt, Adjuncts, and Sugars serving as valuable resources for both homebrewers and professional brewers.

***

Button

TM

THE ART AND SCIENCE OF

BREWING

Traditional Techniques

Modern Innovations

and Future Trends 

© 2024 Jeffrey W. Bulger.  All rights reserved.